1 PoLAR Operations
During our first year in office, the Board read manuscripts at a breakneck pace: we voted every two weeks, for over six months, followed by voting every three weeks for another six months. We developed evaluation standards for initial (R0) and late-stage (R2 and beyond) submissions. We voted both synchronously and by electronic poll. We developed and reconsidered policies: How many reviews are required per manuscript, how many rounds of review are required, and what makes for a supportive and functional “special collection” process, among dozens of other issues. This extraordinary effort was only made possible by the breathtaking commitment of our Associate Editors, and I remain profoundly grateful to them for their labor.
In 2026, our efforts began to pay off. Having cleared our backlog, we were able to scale back manuscript evaluations to once per month per editor and to shift manuscript votes to synchronous conversations. The special collection policy that we approved in August was tested twice, as we received and evaluated proposals from guest editors. I’m delighted to announce that PoLAR approved two special collections slated for publication in 2027 and has received expressions of interest for another three.
These operational shifts are indications of progress. They reflect the Board’s ability to turn our energies toward issues that, I suspect, many of us imagined would be the core of our editorial labors. Now, we are refining editorial standards, feedback structures, and commentary practices—we are, in other words, engaging in the conversations that a healthy editorial staff regularly undertakes. This quarter, for instance, we debated types of feedback for R0 manuscripts. Earlier this year, we refined our special collection policy after two initial experiences with it revealed avenues for improvement. It is a noticeable and welcome shift.
That is not to say that our work is done. These adjustments—these refinements—represent the normal, ongoing, work of a scholarly journal. While more of this work lies ahead, we have made tremendous progress toward providing authors, reviewers, readers—and, yes, editors—with systems that are fair, responsive, and rigorous.
2 Securing PoLAR’s Future
Alongside these improvements, PoLAR has been working to secure its future within the constraints established by the AAA. As I’ve communicated in previous letters, in early 2025, the AAA announced its intention to reduce its journal portfolio. Since then, the AAA has floated various options for the dozen or so journals it no longer intends to publish as part of the prime portfolio—a category that includes PoLAR. PoLAR and its sponsoring section, the Association for Political and Legal Anthropology (APLA), spent the first half of 2025 identifying paths to continued publication. In Fall 2025, we were thrilled to receive an offer from Cambridge University Press (CUP). The AAA’s Executive Board granted APLA and PoLAR permission to pursue that offer in early 2026. This permission was necessary because the AAA—not APLA—owns the copyright to PoLAR, and hence any publication agreement must be between the AAA and CUP.
For most of this year, APLA and PoLAR have sought information from the AAA regarding various details of Cambridge’s proposed offer. Other sections and journals have done likewise: PoLAR may have been the first to secure an alternative publication offer, but other journals have sought, developed, and, in at least a few cases, lost publication opportunities of their own. We have all needed the AAA to provide information to and bargain with potential publication partners because we are not legally entitled to do so ourselves.
In PoLAR’s specific case, our first-mover status has meant that we have been educating the AAA regarding the mechanics of transitioning to a multi-publisher model for its portfolio. Because the AAA has historically published most of its journals through a single press (currently Wiley-Blackwell) moving to a multi-publisher model requires legal and logistical arrangements that are both new and complicated. This educational role, though it is involuntary on our part, is also reasonable and inescapable: the AAA has never done what it is now trying to do, and none of its leaders have the expertise in academic publication needed for such a complex endeavor. But it also means that PoLAR has been scaling the steep front end of the AAA’s learning curve.
As this letter goes to publication, the AAA is poised to consider a full draft agreement—prepared by CUP and PoLAR, with help from APLA—and will hopefully vote to accept it. That agreement is the product of monumental labor by journal and section leaders and by the leadership of Cambridge University Press. Collectively, we have written hundreds of emails, participated in dozens of Zoom calls, and produced half a dozen proposals, primers, and supplemental materials to provide the AAA with necessary information. We have done this labor out of a shared commitment to keeping our section’s journal alive and a desire to see it published by one of the oldest and most respected academic publishers in the world. By the time you read this letter, the AAA will have decided whether—having declared that it no longer wishes to publish PoLAR (and several other journals)—it will support PoLAR and APLA along the promising path we have carved for ourselves and the scholarly communities we serve.
In the meantime, I join the rest of PoLAR’s editorial staff in stewarding the work of those colleagues who share their scholarship with one another through this journal. I am profoundly thankful to do this work alongside a fantastic editorial team: Hayal Akarsu, Matt Canfield, Simanti Dasgupta, Monica Eppinger, Gökçe Günel, Julia Hornberger, Jeff Kahn, Neil Kaplan-Kelly, Meghan Morris, Jeffrey Omari, Mayur Suresh, and Riaz Tejani (Associate Editors); Jennifer Curtis (Associate Editor for PoLAR Online); Alreem Alameri, Alaa Hajyahia, Shalini Iyengar, and Heyu Zhang (Scholarship Liaisons); and Christy Quinto (Managing Editor). We, in turn, are grateful for the vital support of the following colleagues who have shared their expertise with us by reviewing an article or NFF manuscript between April and September 2026, or by reviewing a contribution to our inaugural NFF collection:
Giuseppe Amatulli
Carolina Angel Botero
Anya Bernstein
Tom Bratrud
Melissa Crouch
Jennifer Curtis
Thomas A. De Pree
Ana Del Conde
Georgia Ennis
Matthew Erie
Marie-Claire Foblets
Sandhya Fuchs
Brady G’Sell
Ilana Gershon
Sahana Ghosh
Nisa Göksel
Jessica Greenberg
Martijn Koster
Myles Lennon
Jinee Lokaneeta
Liam Mayes
Gabriela Morales
Michelle Morgenstern
Till Mostowlansky
Paul Nadasdy
Karime Parodi Ambel
Andrea Pia
Vibhuti Ramachandran
Alison Renteln
Paloma Rodrigo Gonzalez
Giuliana Sanò
Ileana Selejan
Rachel Sieder
Amitpal Singh
Jay Sosa
Marika Sosnowski
Leilah Sohrab Vevaina
Robin Wright
Laura Zanotti
Jerry C. Zee
Deepa Das Acevedo, Emory University, is Editor-in-Chief of PoLAR: Political and Legal Anthropology Review.
Book Review Editorial
Political and Legal Anthropology as Democracy Hangs in the Balance
Neil Kaplan-Kelly & Jeffrey Omari
Research Articles
Book Reviews
Living Right: Far-Right Youth Activists in Contemporary Europe. By Agnieszka Pasieka. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2024.
Jessica R. Greenberg
Teraanga Republic: Women’s Authority and Politics in Senegal. By Emily Jenan Riley. Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 2025.
Miriam Jerotich Kilimo
Against Innocence: Undoing and Remaking the World. By Miriam Ticktin. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2025.
Lachlan Summers
